Portion of Garmin Fitness Report for Week Ended 12–11–22 (Author)

Member-only story

Being Fit: Can We Ever Dispel The Calories In-Calories Out Myth?

Or why what you eat and how you live matters, not just calories

Amy Sterling Casil
6 min readDec 12, 2022

--

You see above, my cardio and steps for the past week. I’m fit. I’m healthy. It was an active week, but you can see I couldn’t even crack an average of 2,000 calories burned despite a hefty increase in the amount of cardio minutes I did and a significant increase in the average number of steps I took per day.

If I’d been eating like many others do, I may have been this active, and even gained weight!

Of course I did not gain weight: I eat a pretty standard diet most days. When I deviate from it, I know I can quickly get on track the next day.

I recently saw a fellow Noom user (I am going off the app in a couple of months — I don’t need it any longer and have long-since completed the program) say that they had followed a strict macrobiotic diet for a decade, eating less than 1,600 calories a day, “primarily barley and wheat.” The result? Over this time, the person gained 100 pounds, and was presently using the Noom service to lose the large amount of weight.

The — by this time — moronic and crude mantra of “eat fewer calories than you burn per day” and you will lose weight — it drives me crazy, it is so wrong and bass-ackward and…

--

--

Amy Sterling Casil
Amy Sterling Casil

Written by Amy Sterling Casil

Over 500 million views and 5 million published words, top writer in health and social media. Author of 50 books, former exec, Nebula nominee.

Responses (3)